NXKnowledge

Content Migration Manager > Knowledge base > SolidWorks

CMM solo Solidworks NX issues with extrude feature definitions "Through all"

CMM solo Solidworks NX issues with extrude feature definitions "Through all" IR Number: 8401538

       Priority:	1

Business Urgency: No

   GTAC Urgency:	No

      PR Matrix:	Wrong Result

Problem Description:

================================

When translating SolidWorks Extrude Features to NX Extrude Features, some Extrude Feature Options get misinterpreted by the translator which results in invalid parts.

For instance a SolidWorks extrude definition "Through all" will end up with ˆDistance Value" in NX but with wrong values. Because NX missed the limiting face.

Application/Function: CMM Solid Works -> Extrude Feature

Common/Part specific: unknown

=============================================================================

Versions:

================================

NX 12.0.2.9 MP3

CMM 12.0.2

SolidWorks 2018 SP3

Managed Mode: No

Zip File Containing:

================================

Part: Yes

AVI: no

Syslog: Yes

Other Files: Yes

Steps to Duplicate:

================================

  1. CMM 1308111~01.SLDPRT

  2. SolidWorks Extrude (10) "Balgverbreiterung" with option ˆThrough All" created in Solid Works will end up in NX with wrong ˆDistance Value".

See PPT for details and how to reproduce.

==> ERROR: No error message, extrude feature was not created "Through All" but with wrong ˆDistance Values".

Work Around:

================================

unknown

Expectation:

================================

Extrude Feature must be created "Through All" or with ˆDistance Values" similar it was defined in SolidWorks.

Problem is part specific:

================================

unknown

Platform Information:

================================

Problem is platform specific: no

Platform: Intel Win764-bit

Problem verified on the following platforms and OS versions:

Intel Win764-bit, NX 12.0.2.9 MP3, CMM 12.0.2, SolidWorks 2018 SP3

Additional Notes:

================================

This issue is currently open and under investigation. When the investigation completes, this article will be updated to include all of the pertinent information and conclusions. If you have further questions related to this article, or any article, please contact Support for assistance. PR 8401538 Product Information: Product: NX , Application: CMM , Version: V12.0.2

Source: https://support.sw.siemens.com/en-US/knowledge-base/PL8115747 · retrieved 2026-10-02